But Trachtenberg’s Dawn was so adorably awkward, so meltingly vulnerable, that it wasn’t long before the show’s fans embraced her. If you were Dawn’s age, you related to her; if you were older, you felt protective of her. Trachtenberg, who died on Feb. 26 at age 39, was a stealthy charmer. Her presence in early-2000s TV—later, she would play the scheming socialite Georgina Sparks on Gossip Girl—exemplifies the hold that even secondary characters can have on us. You don’t have to be the star of the show to earn viewers’ affection and loyalty, as Trachtenberg did.
She started her career doing TV commercials at age 3. At 10, she made her film debut in Harriet the Spy (1996). Post-Buffy, she played supporting roles in films like Mysterious Skin (2004) and Cop Out (2010), though her finest hour in the movie realm may be as the swe...